The Novus Ordo becomes a cult of toxic innovation [parody alert]

The following guest post comes to us from a young Catholic woman who is a friend of the site and long time reader of the Liturgy Guy blog. It is written in response to a recent article at the National Catholic Reporter Distorter, The Latin Mass becomes a cult of toxic tradition. That embarrassingly amateurish diatribe does not deserve a serious rebuttal, but it does warrant a response, and humor (in this case parody) seems most appropriate.

One culture within the Catholic Church needing major reform is that surrounding the practice of the Novus Ordo Mass.

In the wake of completely unnecessary liturgical reforms instituted by the Second Vatican Council, the Novus Ordo Mass has become a rallying point for modernist, anti-Catholic sects that desperately seek to change the Church. The ultra-liberal Marxism practiced by these Novus Ordo groups is radical and narrow-minded.

The Novus Ordo fosters clericalist structures in the Church. The liturgy – spoken in the vernacular, thus alienating immigrants, migrants, and any Catholic not from a particular country – places all power in the hands of the priest. The priest spends most of the Mass looking at the people and incorporating his personality into the ceremony. The congregation is barely able to actively participate, let alone pray, because they are being smothered with music from the St. Louis Jesuits and subjected to the liturgical mosh pit known as the “sign of peace.”

All people inside the church are expected to kneel on cue at various points, unless it’s a really left-wing Novus Ordo where the priest tells people they should stand during the Consecration.

The priest is at the center of the spectacle. He is separated from the people he is supposed to serve by felt banners – a barrier that gives him privileges. To receive the Eucharist, people must hold out their hands to the Extraordinarily Unnecessary Fake Minister of Holy Communion or be subjected to a fake blessing from said baby boomer.

Meanwhile, the Novus Ordo innovation oppresses women. Women are expected – indeed, in some cases commanded – not to cover their heads as has been Christian tradition for millennia. It is a total denial of the sacredness of women and the respect men are to show them, as well as the desire of many women to veil. It is discrimination, and therefore the Novus Ordo actively endorses sexism. Instead of a unifying form of worship, the Novus Ordo is often unrecognizable from place to place because of the many liturgical abuses. It has become a gathering point for modernists who deny key tenets of the Catholic faith.

In most cases, it is useless to politely disagree with people in the Novus Ordo sect. Their attitude creates blindness — not only to true faith, but to their own behavior. They treat others with pride and animosity, but their conscience fails to kick in because they are convinced their way is holy and other ways are not. And they call anyone who doesn’t belong to their sect schismatic or sedevacantist.

Anyone who may accuse me of not knowing what I’m talking about — a favorite indictment of the Novus Ordo ideologues — would be wrong. My opinion is based on facts and personal experiences.

I recently went to a Novus Ordo Mass with a relative who grew up before Vatican II, and the treatment we got was so judgmental. Anything looking remotely female was completely trying to be male. The people were all washed up 1970s hippies, and the pastor, arrayed in hideous vestments, was more like a circus clown. After over an hour spent drowning in the Fake Eucharistic Ministers’ hand sanitizer and getting sneered at for trying to pray, we did not feel any closer to God.

Rules, also, were a strange issue. For example, veils wereforbidden to be worn in the church. A confessor there hit one of my family members with the penance of “smile at someone tomorrow.”

After some while of this torture, my mother spoke with a different priest about the idiotic penances. He advised her that the genuine Catholic faith does not actually teach that sin is real, so there is no need to do any penance, let alone go to Confession. Immediately we stopped going to Mass at that parish.

But it wasn’t the last time I would run into Novus Ordo Masses— or the Novus Ordo sectarians, present today in many Catholic organizations.

After almost leaving the church as a teenager, I decided to stay Catholic and parish hop on Sundays so I could experience the polka Mass, the clown Mass, and the folk Mass depending on where I was.

One time, a priest noticed I was showing up semi-regularly and approached me with a persuasive speech to convert me to the Novus Ordo faction — disguising discrimination as encouragement. “You should be an altar server at the Novus Ordo Mass. Women look the most beautiful in church when they are dressed in an alb – we don’t do a cassock and surplice here, of course.”

It should come as no surprise that a contingent of men active within the sectarian Novus Ordo environment are total beta males. These types believe they are inferior to women simply because they are male. Most concerning is their inability to lead as Christ has called men to lead. These men did not want to associate with women unless those women attempt to religiously dominate them.

Men in this Novus Ordo peer group interview young women about their career goals before deciding to spend time with them. If they express any desire to be a mother before age 35, they’re ostracized and oppressed.

Unsurprisingly, while at the Novus Ordo I had another memorably bad experience. I asked to receive Communion kneeling and on the tongue, because I believe the Eucharist really is the body, blood, soul, and divinity of Jesus Christ. Most Novus Ordo-type priests I’d encountered in my lifetime would give me the Eucharist kneeling and on the tongue, albeit somewhat begrudgingly. Not this pastor. He literally made a scene at the altar and jerked the Eucharist away from me when I knelt downto receive it — as if it was somehow disrespectful to Our Lord to present myself in a reverent posture.

I seriously considered walking out of the church at that point, but decided to receive the Eucharist instead since I wanted to pray. After Mass I gave the priests a piece of my mind.

Clericalism defined the response I received. When I informed an assisting priest that the pastor had been very rude to me at the altar and asked that my views be relayed, he replied: “I won’t throw our pastor under the bus. He’s the pastor. I refuse to tell him to correct his behavior.”

He continued, “the bishop is totally on our side, so don’t even bother trying to write a letter. It’ll go straight to his trashcan.”

I reminded him that, as a priest, he was supposed to uphold the Catholic faith. The priest took a step back and looked at me in astonishment, as if that notion had never occurred to him. “Very well. I’ll tell the pastor what you said,” he said condescendingly. “But I don’t think he did anything wrong.”

His attitude was a trademark example of the culture within the Catholic Church that encourages abuse. His first reaction was to default to absolute loyalty to his Novus Ordo pastor, then dismiss my views. When pressed further, he flat-out denied all wrongdoing. To Novus Ordo clericalists, complainers are always the problem — not those who are committing liturgical abuses and preaching heresy.

With feudalistic rigidity, the priest argued in defense of his pastor against the traditions of the “Church before Vatican II” —a derogatory phrase used by Novus Ordo cultists to denote regular Catholic Masses. He said the Masses I regularly attended were “outdated” and “abolished” and insisted they were only “allowed to exist, but not standardly recommended.” He claimed the Church only allowed kneeling for Holy Communion “in extreme cases.” Of course, I know this is not true. He capped his radical fundamentalist arguments by saying the Novus Ordo, despite literally being invented half a century ago by a man who likely was a Freemason, is a solemn rite equal to Byzantine and Coptic rites and that rules cannot be changed for anyone. He accused me of being “rude” by expecting them “to not change their rites.”

What I gained from this experience was a deeper recognition of how the Novus Ordo Mass foments the clericalist culture within the Catholic Church that Pope Francis is actively working to continue.

Posted on November 7, 2019, in liturgy and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 14 Comments.

  1. This may be parody, yes; but it’s completely true, the polar opposite of its target article! Amazingly done.

  2. Brilliant. But the ‘Catholic’ Reporter is best ignored I feel.

  3. catholictradition2


  4. WARNING! WEAR YOUR HIP WAITERS BEFORE READING. Get your facts straight before writting your article.

    • They are known as hip waders.

      The above article was spot on and the facts were actually very accurate. I’m not sure where you go to Church, but I can attest to seeing many of the things written that were absolutely present in the Novus Ordo Masses I’ve attended over the years.

  5. The person who wrote the NCR article has problems alright.
    However, the problems are not with the Mass.

  6. Wow! what a terrible experience I would have complained to the Cardinal. But not all Novus Ordo Masses are like that. The one at St. Margaret Mary in Oakland is fantastic. It is mostly in Latin, has only male altar servers and readers, is ad Orientum, uses the altar rail and has Gregorian chant. But I do go to the Extraordinary Form now because its not just the actions done at the Novus Ordo that is the problem it is the words at Mass. Lots of the prayers that were in the Extraordinary Form were cut out. They are so solid but at the Novus Ordo the prayers are so mundane.
    I honestly believe that if there has to be a Novus Ordo Mass why can’t we go back to using the 1969 version. This transitionary Mass came before the official one in 1970 (albeit extremely watered down). It has the prayers at the foot of the altar and can be done in Latin.

    • @Sarah
      The article here is a parody of an article written by a National Catholic Reporter correspondent who used the above examples to attack the TLM. A young woman wrote the article tongue in cheek to highlight the ad hominem and red herring arguments of said NCR correspondent (Zita Fletcher).

  7. What parody? Sounds like all the V2 Catholic priests and laity I know.

  8. > Brian Williams posted: ” The following guest post comes to us from a young > Catholic woman who is a friend of the site and long time reader of the > Liturgy Guy blog. It is written in response to a recent article at the > National Catholic Reporter Distorter, The Latin Mass becomes ” >

  9. Bernie Whitworth

    I absolutely agree with what was said in this article. Eight years ago I converted from Protestantism to Catholicism because I discovered the beauty and profound spirituality in the traditional mass. Now I see myself more and more confronted with this Novus Ordo nonsense and its notorious conformity with the Protestant liturgy. So why convert at all?
    Maybe this disastrous development is the hallmark of Antichrist incarnating within the Church. I could leave tomorrow but I decided to stay for the sake of the true Church behind the fake Deep Church. Let us support each other in our traditional belief and connection with the sacred Heart of Jesus. The true Church will prevail against false spirit that tries to destroy it. Ad orientem we pray!

  10. katzenellenbogen

    When the pastor refused to give You the Holy Sacrament because You were kneeling, You might have said: “Oh, I am not kneeling because of Our Lord, I am kneeling in the same way as the football players before the match begins, as a protest against racism!” I am sure the priest would have suddenly changed his mind and begun to like You…

  11. ServeGodnotman

    God allowed the novus order to be called such so that the faithful have a simple acronym to help answer the question if we should attend, N.O.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: